Shadow And Act on Facebook

Can Perry Sing A Jazz Man’s Blues…?

Jazz Man painting by Nathaniel Gawayne Sutton (www.finartamerica.com)

Jazz Man painting by Nathaniel Gawayne Sutton (www.finartamerica.com)

OK, so here’s a plot summary, of a period romance/musical drama, A Jazz Man’s Blues, courtesy of ioncinema.com:

A Jazz Man’s Blues is set in the post-World War II South, where a young black jazz singer leaves his rural town in search of fame. During his absence, it’s discovered that he had an affair with a local married woman. But all is not as it seems: the woman is actually his former lover and a light skinned black who has been passing as white. Her racist husband has no idea about her color or her past, and organizes the local Klan chapter to hunt down the jazz singer. Now a successful performer in Chicago, the jazz singer finds himself drawn back South to help save his mother’s ailing nightclub and face his accusers.

Interesting pemise, methinks. I’d certainly pay to see this if it ever got made. However, I wonder what the chances are of a movie like this getting made and distributed, even on a limited release, especially if Hollywood has anything to do with it. I’m guessing that unless you’re Tyler Perry, the chances are pretty slim.

Oh, wait… did I forget to mention that this is a Tyler Perry movie and it’s being co-produced (along with Perry’s self named production company) and distributed by none other than Lions Gate? According to a now deleted Wikipedia page, it was originally set for a June 09 release but is currently listed on IMDB Pro as being in-development with an unspecified 2010 release date.

So… Tyler Perry doing a period drama… A period drama that would appear to have some weight and cover a topic that’s sure to court controversy in these um… post-racial times… Tyler Perry!!??!! And no, he’s not just producing, if that’s what you’d hope, but is set to star and direct, and wrote the script himself… Oh dear.

Unless you’re new to these parts, it’s no great secret that TP gets short shrift on this site. Was there an uproar when it was announced that he’d taken over the production of For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When The Rainbow Is Not Enuf, even though new comer, Nzingha Stewart had alread secured interest from Lions Gate with her script adaptation of the book…? Oh, hell yeah! Were we impressed when it was announced that he had signed on to be executive producer of Lee Daniels‘ Sundance sensation, Precious after it had already gone on to wow the global festival circuit…? Well, at best he was an opportunist and at worst he was Lions Gate’s ploy to secure an audience for a film that they had publicly fought (with The Weinstien Company) to acquire but which they had no idea how to market – it’s about an illiterate fat black chick, for Chrissakes! Perry could help bring in his mainly black fanbase and co-exec. producer Oprah could help bring in her mainly white fanbase…

But I’m beginning to see more than just a purveyor of stereotypical, buffoonish black  characters and weak, simplistic morality tales. Lurking somehwere under that dragtastic Madea fat suit seems to be a shrewd business man who didn’t just happen upon some good fortune simply by giving Whitey what he wants… okay, so maybe he did, but it also seems to be what many money paying black people want too. And, anyway, isn’t giving Whitey what he wants what many African-Americans have had to do for centuries in order to get ahead? The trick, of course, is being able to do it AND get ahead! No mean feat, it would seem, especially when conscious brothers and sisters are screaming “sell-out!” at your every sickening, steeped in stereotype mov(i)e. But much to the disdain and dismay of the more high-brow (and thus less financially well off) among us, some have cracked it, particularly the more savvy in the music/hip-hop industry. Perry, it would seem, is the fey Curtis “50 Cent” Jackson of film.

I found the following excerpt in an interview on CanMag.com in February 2007, in which Perry says of A Jazz Man’s Blues:

“I play a jazz singer in 1947 who’s in love with a woman that’s passing for white, who’s married to someone in the town,” Perry said. “I meet up with a Holocaust survivor who becomes my manager and my character becomes the biggest jazz singer in the world and comes back to get this woman. It’s a straight drama. It’s a departure from anything I’ve done. It was written 12 years ago. So I had to do these movies in order to have the leverage to do this one.”

I’ve never seen a Perry movie. To the best of my knowledge, none of his films have been released in the UK nor, in fact, anywhere outside of North America, though please feel free correct me if I’m wrong on this point. I’ve seen online trailers for some of his movies, none of which have piqued my interest particularly, I’ve seen posters when visiting the US… At this juncture, however, even though popular opinion among people whose opinions I actually bother to listen to would suggest that he’s far from being the best African-American filmmaker that ever graced our screens, I’ve actually reached the point (or his name has actually become so unavoidable) where I’m prepared to sit through a TP movie… probably not something that has his cash cow character, Madea, in it… maybe something more star-studded and potentially relevant to my life like Why Did I Get Married? If it ever came on Film Four, Sky Drama or Sky Indie, yes, I’d most probably watch it – if only to get an idea of just how bad he really is as a filmmaker – a charge which could be levelled at many a Hollywood hack who isn’t black.

Even without having seen any of his films, however, I can’t help but think that perhaps it’s about time he stopped behaving like a cash strapped, ambitious, high on ideas but talent-deficient indie filmmaker and started getting other people who know their craft to actually star in, write and direct his future projects for him ( i.e. maybe it’s time he started behaving like the big-time film producer he’s either astutely or inadvertently become, and give other people – actors, writers, director… and audiences – a break).

But maybe Perry has something up his sleeve, perhaps his climbing on the critically acclaimed Precious band-wagon was a shrewdness more on his part than on Lions Gate’s. Pushing back the release of A Jazz Man’s Blues from June 09 to a likely similar time next year certainly gave both Lions Gate and Perry the opportunity to get behind a race senstive movie and gauge audience reaction to it. Given their surprise success with his movies, perhaps he’s convinced them that, as profitable as his light weight dramas have been, there’s only so long that those kinds of movies can keep ‘em coming in.

There’s little doubt he has their ear. Perhaps, unbeknown to us, he’s been banging the diversification drum quietly in that ear and convinced them that a project like A Jazz Man’s Blues is something that movie audiences, particularly black audiences, are waiting to see.  There’s little doubt that his repeated commercial successes warmed them to the idea of other “black” projects like Precious and For Colored Girls, and they certainly seemed to hand For Colored Girls over to him without much ado…. They took a chance on Perry when no-one else would and its been paying off handsomely ever since.

A few weeks ago, Tambay posed the question “Does The Success of Precious Mean Anything For Black Cinema?” Well, it seems to me that Perry and Lionsgate have been willing to bet on it. We’ve joked on this site from time to time that Lions Gate is becoming the go-to studio for black film projects. I’m not sure if that feeling in my stomach is queasiness or excitement, but I suspect that at least initially (since other studios are bound to want to cash in to the next “race” movie phase) all roads to Lions Gate will go through Mr Perry…

10 comments to Can Perry Sing A Jazz Man’s Blues…?

  • ladybug

    Ugh . . . someone please tell this man that he is neither a writer , director, nor an actor. . . not good ones anyway. The concept interesting . . Tyler Perry playing a jazz singer . . . in a period film . . . come on!

  • I thought this sounded familiar. I blurbed about it on The Obenson Report earlier this year, before Shadow & Act was born. There was mention in an article at the time in which Perry said he was going after Diana Ross to star in the film – although I’m not sure what character she would play. I doubt she’d be the woman the jazz man falls in love with. Diana Ross may be fair-skinned, but she wouldn’t have passed for white in the 1940s. Plus she doesn’t quite resemble the Diana Ross of yesteryear; she’s 65 years old. She likely plays his mother, who owns the nightclub.

    In the interview, he also stated that Ben Kingsley, Cicely Tyson, and Kimberly Elise, were to be in it as well. Tyson and Elise have previously worked with him before, so no surprises there, but Ben Kingsley??? Gandhi? That I’d have to see! Then again, he has done his share of bad movies. But I’m having a really difficult time seeing him comfortably in a Tyler Perry movie.

    He said he wouldn’t make the movie until he gets the cast that he wants, so given how powerful he’s become in the last 12 months alone, I think it’s safe to say that he just may get everyone – even Kingsley.

  • theyounglion

    Ben Kingsley co-starred in a Uwe Boll film (”BloodRayne”) a few years back. To say he looked uncomfortable and out-of-place in the movie would be an understatement. (Yeah, I watched it…sometimes there’s nothing better than bad movies on cable on a Saturday afternoon/night.) He still does prestige stuff…but that proves he’ll do anything if the conditions (meaning, I assume, the $$$) are right.

  • LJW

    Why do YOU and others when writing about Tyler Perry use the word “buffoonish” when you know dayum well you never used that word growing up, in your household? Your friends didnt use that word, your cousins didnt use that word. Why are you adopting and foster parenting these GHETTO azz words? Stop it!! UGH.

    And by the way… Tyler Perry donated 1 million dollars to the NAACP………. CAN YOU DO THAT? Walking away……. I didnt think so.

    BE BLESSED!
    LJW

    • Sorry… Do I KNOW you?

      No. And I don’t see why you should presume to know me, either. As it happens, the word “buffoon” was used quite extensively in my youth by various people around me. Oddly enough, I’ve also come across it in books, many of which I discovered before the advent of the success of Mr Perry.

      I’d now like to direct you to a post on this site that reminds us that Black People are NOT a monolith… and yes, that would mean that we don’t all have a $1m to our name, though what point you were trying to make there, I’m not too sure.

  • Art

    “I play a jazz singer in 1947 who’s in love with a woman…”

    Unbelievable! 10 yards.

    “I meet up with a Holocaust survivor who becomes my manager…”

    Pandering! 15 yards.

  • AccidentalVisitor

    Reading about this potential movie a few weeks back I wondered why again must there be some tragic mulatto/pass-for-white character who is female? And of course such a character is always married/attached to a white guy. I’ve read so many comments on this site about plotlines being played out and let me suggest that this plot is one of them. Hollywod has done stories like this for decades going back to the 1930s I believe. Has a story ever been done around that era in which the black character that passes for white is actually a male and married to a white female? How about having the black jazz player being in a doomed relationship (considering the era and region) with a white female? Yes, I know Tyler would never do such a film (it would be an insult to all black women, yada, yada, yada) but has any other writer/filmmaker tried? You see if knuckleheads like Allison Samuels is going to accuse real life black men of not being invested in the black family and for always hooking up with white chicks and other non-black women, can we at least see that so-called “reality” represented on the big screen?

    • Uh AccidentalTourist, I do recall ‘The Human Stain’ covered the black man passing for white and married to a white woman topic. Don’t you remember. Although a Black man did not star in the lead role (it was Anthony Hopkins) the purpose was still the same and Wentworth Miller (who is black biracial) played him in his youth.

      In any case, here’s the key part of MsWOO’s post that I agree with:

      getting other people who know their craft to actually star in, write and direct his future projects for him ( i.e. maybe it’s time he started behaving like the big-time film producer he’s either astutely or inadvertently become, and give other people – actors, writers, director… and audiences – a break).

      Mr. Perry has shown that he is indeed a masterful business man and a Producer that can get things done, but I agree, the stories that are being told are one note. We need more creative voices. I don’t understand what the issue is with working together. Tyler got put on, and yes he’s giving black actresses and actors work, but what about the writers WE WRITERS ARE THE HEART OF FILMS! For gawd’s sake! And what about directors? There are so many out there, men and women who are not being given a chance. C’mon Tyler, I don’t like to bash but enough is enough.

  • I'm A Stranger Here Myself

    Isn’t this basically Walter Mosley’s book & Carl Franklin’s movie Devil in a Blue Dress.
    You state that Lionsgate is the go to studio for Black projects, well what happened to Sony’s Black production arm or the Weinstein’s. It’ll take one Turkey at the Box Office to kill Lionsgate’s interest in Black film. Plus there interest only appears to extend to one T Perry esq.
    Finally, TP as a fey 50 Cent thats go to be the line of the year (Girl you 2 years too late for The Wire script gig).

  • Tyler Perry’s archaic,derivative writing is emblematic of the sorry state of alternative filmmaking and the sad,sob blues itself, Jazz Man’s Blues,huh? i can see it now, his dry roasted characters, dipped in a cauldron of chocolate and open veins running with battery acid!

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>